“I was given a car loan but disallowed a business
loan because of my disability.”
— Samuel Mani, entrepreneur, supported by Microsoft
Access to financial services for the
The historical inactivity of decision-making has impacted disabled the most in India. Neither are any decisions taken to help them live with dignity, nor is anyone bothered about this small constituency, which is not a vote bank. Team INCLUSION analyses
Financial inclusion is integral to economic development and growth. With the advancement in technology and expansion of banking services people are getting increasingly dependent on debit and credit cards, cheque-books and Internet and telephone banking in their day-to-day activities. Imagine suddenly due to some unfortunate accident you are not able to carry out routine banking activities like withdrawing money from ATM or bank branch and signing cheque. For most of us this is unthinkable. But the persons with disabilities face this challenge every day.
In addition to the basic rights that they enjoy as human beings; the persons with disabilities need support mechanism to access banking and financial services. But the reality is starkly different. Despite the legal provisions of equal rights, differently-abled persons are often denied services and are subjected to discrimination and humiliation. Denial of banking services affects their employment, security, privacy, dignity and empowerment.
Persons with special needs and various stakeholders, INCLUSION spoke to, were unanimous that there is widespread discrimination and general refusal of banking services to differently-abled people. Persons with disabilities are often denied the services on the ground that they can’t see, or sign or that they are intellectually disabled to understand the banking transactions.
Self Help Groups of Persons with Disabilities are also denied the banking facilities on the ground that they have members who are minors or who are intellectually disabled and thus can’t be involved in banking transactions with other people as per the Contract Act.
Challenges are enormous. Even if some persons with disabilities are allowed to open bank accounts, they face challenges in accessing the services due to barriers in infrastructure, operations and attitude.
As per a RBI guideline issued in July 2011, banks need to make provisions of ramps, talking ATMs with Braille keypads. However, these guidelines have hardly been implemented.
Out of nearly 160,000 Automated Teller Machines (ATMs) in the country, only 6,000 have provisions of ramps, talking ATMs with Braille keypads. This means, almost 96 out of the 100 ATMs in the country are not accessible for the people with special needs. As per the RBI guidelines a third of ATMs within city limits should be made accessible to the persons with disabilities.
“Most ATMs have
which may say like
hello, welcome, byebye.
This does not
serve the purpose.”
— Sam Taraporevala, Associate Professor, St Xavier’s College, Mumbai
RBI guidelines also ensures that all the banking facilities such as cheque book facility including third party cheques, ATM facility, net banking facility, locker facility, retail loans and credit cards are invariably offered to the visually challenged without any discrimination.
However, the ground reality is different and extremely disappointing. People with disabilities are forced to run from pillar to post to get even basic banking services.
Poonam Natarajan, Chairperson, National Trust for welfare of persons with autism, cerebral palsy, mental retardation and multiple disabilities at the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment of the Government of India, said there are a lot of myths about the persons with disabilities that need to be busted.
She said despite assurances and guidelines, persons with disabilities face a lot of hardships and the ground reality is very disturbing.
“If I come to you with a ten million
deposit, will you accept the deposit
because of the amount or reject it
because of my cerebral palsy?”
— Siddharth Jaykumar,
a serving banker with cerebral palsy
For opening of accounts for the persons with cerebral palsy, autism, mental retardation and multiple disabilities banks often ask for guardianship certificate and also insist on having a guardian as joint account holder, who will be responsible for operating the account. Banks continue to insist for guardianship certificate despite the clarification from the RBI that guardianship is not necessary for all the persons suffering from cerebral palsy, autism, mental retardation and multiple disabilities.
In such cases, even if banking services are extended to the persons with disabilities on paper, practically they hardly enjoy the services. Most persons with cerebral palsy, visual impairment is only allowed to open joint accounts. In these cases the authority of signing cheques and availing other banking facilities are extended to the joint account holder who is a normal person, it could be a family member or care taker. In majority of the cases banking transactions are executed by the guardian or joint account holder without the knowledge of the persons with disability, who is a joint account holder.
In majority of the cases, persons with disabilities are forced to opt for guardianship even if he or she doesn’t really need one.
The National Trust that works for the welfare of the persons with cerebral palsy, autism, mental retardation and multiple disabilities has written to the RBI highlighting the problems faced by these people.
“Disabilities are diverse. Each one may need a different support. We need to look at how the people with different kind of disabilities can become part of productive section of society,” said Natarajan.
Smitha of Disability Law Unit (South) said there is need for change in the mindset as in most of the cases banking sector do not see disabled people as potential customers.
She said situation in rural areas is far more disturbing as in majority of the cases persons with intellectual disabilities are denied even opening savings accounts despite having a guardian. Minors with intellectual disabilities are denied opening of accounts as they could not have a guardian before 18 years.
“Rural banks deny savings account to many persons with physical, visual or hearing disabilities by delaying the process of initiating an account, which doesn’t carry evidence,” she said.
Postal savings accounts are completely denied to people with intellectual disabilities. Though people with physical disabilities are provided postal accounts, they are denied active roles in further operations of their account.
“We are either refused insurance
or charged a hefty premium. A PIL
has been filed against insurance
— Smita, Asst. Coordinator,
Disability Law Unit, Chennai
Persons with intellectual disabilities are denied current account. Thumb impression is not accepted in current account. Even the companies owned by persons with intellectual disability are not allowed to run current accounts.
Persons with disabilities generally denied or face huge problems in accessing loans. In most of the cases they are not given individual education loans. They have to provide the surety of two people to avail the minimum educational loan, which is not in the case of students without disabilities. Even under the National Handicapped Finance and Development Corporation (NHFDC) they face huge difficulties in getting loans for self-employment ventures. Loans are not provided individually without power of attorney or cheque signing authority to caretaker.
Attitude of insurance companies is far worse, when it comes to providing services to the people with special needs. They are either charged arbitrarily or denied the services altogether.
Assistant Vice President for Actuarial at Star Union Dai-ichi Life Insurance Suresh Narayan Sindhi said insurance premiums on the people with disabilities are high due to higher degree of uncertainties and other factors.
“Disability does not go away just because society becomes richer. Environment has to be enabling. It is always our effort to make services more accessible to the people with special needs”
— Stuti Kacker, Secretary, Department of Disability Affairs
He said the central and state governments and the non-governmental organisations should contribute to make insurance affordable for the people with special needs.
Referring to the RBI regulations, Sam Taraporevala, Associate Professor, St Xavier’s College, Mumbai, said till 2008, visually impaired people were treated by the banks on par with illiterate. The logic behind it was that a visually impaired person could be fooled because he or she can’t see.
“Up to 2008, there was a RBI circular which says all blind persons have to be treated on par with illiterate. As the customer cannot see, he or she may be fooled. We took up a representation with the RBI and in June 2008, we got that changed and then we pushed for an inclusive circular for ATMs,” said Taraporevala.
He said some banks have implemented just part of the technology to be legally correct.
“Most ATMs have default speech, which may say like hello, welcome, bye-bye. This does not serve the purpose. The efforts must be made to make it accessible in true sense,” he said.
“We have the rules for the visually challenged but it is not implemented properly. Rule-making is one thing, and implementation is another,” added Taraporevala, emphasising on the need for strict implementation of the regulations.
He said the banks should use the technology to ensure convenient and safe banking to physically challenged people, especially visually impaired.
Taraporevala pointed out that less than 5 per cent of over 160,000 ATMs in the country have required facilities for the people with special needs. “There is a huge gap. Technology is available. The banks must make more ATMs accessible,” he said.
Chief Executive of Indian Banks’ Association Mohan V Tanksale said no bank could deny services to any person just because he or she has disabilities.
However, Tanksale admitted that people with disabilities face problems due to some systemic as well as individualistic attitude of the people.
“Service industry is unfortunately individualistic. It is the person behind the show, how he reacts, how he really behaves, how he really treats,” said Tanksale highlighting the need for sensitising the people at the ground level.
“Disabilities are diverse. Each one may need a different support. We need to look at how the people with different kind of disabilities can become part of productive section of society”
— Poonam Natarajan, Chairperson, National Trust
“As a banker, we very strongly believe that when we talk of accessibility. It is not only the physical accessibility. It is accessibility of information, it is accessibility of products, it is accessibility of services,” Tanksale added.
Banking services are very important to ensure that benefits of the economic growth percolated to the lowest level of the society. Financial inclusion is seen as a key tool to stimulate growth and rural development, control inflation, and enhance efficiency and transparency in public services. For the differently-abled people, it is particularly important.
With government welfare schemes moving into the cash transfer to beneficiaries’ mode, it has become all the more important to have access to the banking services. With a view to plug the leakages and corruption, even the monthly maintenance allowances disbursed by the government is credited to the bank.
Stuti Kacker, Secretary, Department of Disability Affairs, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, said the environment need to be made enabling for the people with special needs.
Kacker said nearly 10 per cent of India’s population has some sort of disabilities and the government endeavour is to create an enabling environment so that they can live a comfortable life.
“Disability does not go away just because society becomes richer,” said Kacker adding, with the economic development efforts should be made to make the environment conducive for differently-abled people.
“Environment has to be enabling. It is always our effort to make services more accessible to the people with special needs,” she said.
Tulika Das of SANCHAR that works for disabled people in West Bengal said attitudinal barriers are the primary and common cause for discrimination in banking services to the people with disabilities.
She said discrimination and humiliation doubles if the person is from poor rural background. “Starting from opening an account, they face discrimination on every step.”
Das recalled how a public sector bank branch, located near Kolkata forced a person with disability to wait for six months to get pass book after opening of the account.
“Aaj hobe na, pore aasun, kaal aasun (not possible today, come later come tomorrow) and that tomorrow continues month after month,” said Das adding that individual with disabilities was forced to run from pillar to post just to get a pass book. She said this is not an isolated case, but a normal practice in case of providing services to the persons with disabilities.
Discrimination and denying banking and financial services to the persons with disabilities is not just against the spirit of domestic and international regulations, but also against humanity, and it must be stopped.
As per the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, it is the duty of the States to prohibit all discrimination on the basis of disability and guarantee to persons with disabilities equal and effective legal protection against discrimination on all grounds.
There is need for change in perspectives. All bank officials and staffs need to be sensitised on the rights of persons with disabilities. They should be given periodic trainings on the provisions pertaining to the banking operations of persons with disabilities and handling of persons with varied disabilities. Sign language interpreters and communication aids should be made available in banks along with signages and Braille notifications of all necessary information.
All bank officials should be sensitised on the rights of and provisions for persons with disabilities in utilising all services provided by the bank as well as a pro-active approach towards persons with disabilities.
Accessibility measures such as ramps, railings, non-slippery flooring, accessible toilets, lowered service counters, additional wheel chairs should be mandated in all bank branches.
The RBI should come up with detailed uniform inclusive procedural guidelines about customers with disabilities. The guidelines should be bifurcated for different disability groups since each group has unique requirements and clubbing them under one will not meet requirements of all. For example, initiatives for the visually impaired may be different from those for cognitive disabilities.
All banks and financial institutions should add the word “disability” in their standard non-discrimination clause where it is mentioned that services will be offered to all without any discrimination based on caste/religion/gender etc.
There should be crosschecks from the bank with the concerned individual with disabilities when a transaction occurs even if it is a small amount before the transaction is processed. It can be done through phone calls, SMS or emails etc.
Facility of banking from home, through a bank executive who comes home to facilitate transactions, should be extended to cover all persons with disabilities in rural and urban areas.
Internet banking and mobile banking shall be promoted for persons with visual, hearing, physical, intellectual, or psycho-social disabilities with a relaxation of rules in internet banking.
For issue of cheques in savings and current accounts, thumb impression should be scanned and digitised. The cheques issued for persons with disabilities should be of different colour from the usual ones to make it easily identifiable when a transaction is made by a person with disability.
RBI should incentivise banks that have more number of consumers with disabilities and conduct programmes to sensitise personnel in all banks on how to deal with Persons with disabilities in a befitting and dignified fashion.
Moreover, there are needs to ensure stricter implementations of the guidelines issued by the RBI and other regulatory agencies.
Economists Agonize Over a ModiNomics Budget Atul K Thakur The new government’s preferences are akin to the developmental thinking of Prime Minister, who puts priority on top and work on that. As clearly visible, the budget underlined some of the key visions configured in the first chapter from ModiNomics......read more
A Budget for Rural India K G Karmakar This budget is not about financial markets, not about reforms, not about kick- starting the economy and is also not about banking reforms and what have you. This is a solid budget for Rural India and if the rural economy is safe, India’s economic growth is not in doubt. This budget is aimed largely at Rural India and we need to look at it from a rural perspective and it begins to make sound economic sense. There are a whole lot of goodies for the rural sector, analyses K G Karmakar...read more
Current Issue »
Q & A »
Indian Financial Sector on the Edge of a Precipice says Yashwant Sinha Excerpts from an interview with Sameer Kochhar, Editor-in-Chief, INCLUSION Question: What do you think of India’s financial sector performance? Answer: We are really on the edge of a precipice in India as far as the financial sector is concerned. A declining, decelerating economy has created enormous problems for our public sector banks ...read more
Feedback - Inclusion:
Effective Leadership Is The Answer
The article by Mr Tarapore on the 'Financial problems of MSMEs' is an excellent piece, a well researched one. RBI, SIDBI et al should look at the issues flagged by the author and see that the MSME sector gets better deal. As he has mentioned it is more a 'glamour' in lending to larger units than MSMEs. See the way every banker has walked in to lend to King Fisher Airlines which has left a huge NPA of over Rs.7000 crore with very little hope of recovering it from the owners. Recently, the newspaper report mentions that the CBI when approached the SBI, the consortium banker to provide certain information on KFA, the latter had refused to do so. The RBI has also not taken any forensic study to see if any complicity in financing such large units. It is sad its own representatives are on the Boards of these banks which have lent huge loans to KFA and others. It is sad to see that Mr Mallaya is happily watching the IPL matches cheer-leading his cricket team while 1000s of KFA employees are in the lurch without any pay for months on. Will RBI listen to the cries of common man?
Dr S Santhanam PhD(Eco), CAIIB General Manager (Retd), NABARD & Consultant - Development Finance Pune
Feedback - Inclusion:
Ideas for Growth, October-December 2013
I appreciate your thoughtfulness. Manohar Parrikar, Chief Minister, Goa